Use top-level postgres.port and existing states to set port

pillar.example

@@ -1,3 +1,7 @@
+# Port to use for the cluster -- can be used to provide a non-standard port
+# NOTE: If already set in the minion config, that value takes priority
+postgres.port: '5432'
+
 postgres:
   # UPSTREAM REPO
   # Set True to configure upstream postgresql.org repository for YUM/APT/ZYPP
@@ -32,13 +36,9 @@ postgres:
     hard: 64000
 
   # POSTGRES
-  # Non-standard port to use for the cluster
-  # Only set if port `5432` is not appropriate
-  port: 5433
-
   # Append the lines under this item to your postgresql.conf file.
   # Pay attention to indent exactly with 4 spaces for all lines.
-  postgresconf: |
+  postgresconf: |-
     listen_addresses = '*'  # listen on all interfaces
 
   # Path to the `pg_hba.conf` file Jinja template on Salt Fileserver

postgres/defaults.yaml

@@ -3,7 +3,6 @@
 postgres:
   use_upstream_repo: True
   version: '9.5'
-  default_port: 5432
   pkg: postgresql
   pkgs_extra: []
   pkg_client: postgresql-client

postgres/macros.jinja

@@ -23,7 +23,6 @@
 {{ state }}-{{ name }}:
   {{ state }}.{{ ensure|default('present') }}:
     {{- format_kwargs(kwarg) }}
-    - db_port: {{ postgres.port|default(postgres.default_port) }}
     - onchanges:
       - test: postgres-reload-modules
 

postgres/server/init.sls

@@ -86,7 +86,19 @@ postgresql-config-dir:
     - require:
       - cmd: postgresql-cluster-prepared
 
-{%- if postgres.postgresconf %}
+{%- set db_port = salt['config.option']('postgres.port') %}
+{%- if db_port %}
+
+postgresql-conf-comment-port:
+  file.comment:
+    - name: {{ postgres.conf_dir }}/postgresql.conf
+    - regex: ^port\s*=.+
+    - require:
+      - file: postgresql-config-dir
+
+{%- endif %}
+
+{%- if postgres.postgresconf or db_port %}
 
 postgresql-conf:
   file.blockreplace:
@@ -94,13 +106,21 @@ postgresql-conf:
     - marker_start: "# Managed by SaltStack: listen_addresses: please do not edit"
     - marker_end: "# Managed by SaltStack: end of salt managed zone --"
     - content: |
+        {%- if postgres.postgresconf %}
         {{ postgres.postgresconf|indent(8) }}
+        {%- endif %}
+        {%- if db_port %}
+        port = {{ db_port }}
+        {%- endif %}
     - show_changes: True
     - append_if_not_found: True
     {#- Detect empty values (none, '') in the config_backup #}
     - backup: {{ postgres.config_backup|default(false, true) }}
     - require:
       - file: postgresql-config-dir
+      {%- if db_port %}
+      - file: postgresql-conf-comment-port
+      {%- endif %}
     - watch_in:
       - service: postgresql-running
 
@@ -184,7 +204,7 @@ postgresql-running:
   service.running:
     - name: {{ postgres.service }}
     - enable: True
-   {% if grains.os not in ('MacOS',) %}
+   {% if grains.os not in ('MacOS',) and not db_port %}
     - reload: True
    {% endif %}
     - watch:
@@ -192,25 +212,3 @@ postgresql-running:
       - file: postgresql-pg_ident
 
 {%- endif %}
-
-{%- if postgres.port|default(false) %}
-
-postgresql-port:
-  file.replace:
-    - name: {{ postgres.conf_dir }}/postgresql.conf
-    - pattern: ^#*\s*(port)\s*=\s*\d{4,5}(\s*).*$
-    - repl: >-
-        \1 = {{ postgres.port }}\2# Managed by SaltStack: please do not edit
-    - flags: 8  # ['MULTILINE']
-    - show_changes: True
-    - append_if_not_found: True
-    - backup: {{ postgres.config_backup|default(false, true) }}
-    - require:
-      - file: postgresql-config-dir
-    - watch_in:
-       - service: postgresql-port
-
-  service.running:
-    - name: {{ postgres.service }}
-
-{%- endif %}